Topstep vs. TradeDay

Topstep vs. TradeDay: A Comprehensive Comparison for Aspiring Traders

When it comes to proprietary trading firms, Topstep and TradeDay are two major players that offer aspiring traders the opportunity to prove their trading skills and access real capital. Both firms specialize in futures trading and provide evaluation programs designed to test traders’ profitability, discipline, and risk management before granting them funded accounts. However, there are distinct differences between the two, including their evaluation processes, risk management policies, profit share models, and other unique features.

In this article, we will compare Topstep and TradeDay to help you make an informed decision about which proprietary trading firm is the best fit for your trading goals.


1. Overview of Topstep

What is Topstep?

Topstep is one of the most well-established and trusted names in the proprietary trading industry. Founded in 2012, Topstep is known for its comprehensive evaluation process, educational resources, and clear path to becoming a funded trader. The firm focuses on futures trading, offering traders the chance to prove their skills through a two-phase evaluation process, after which successful traders are granted a funded account to trade real capital.

Key Features:

  • Evaluation Process: Topstep employs a two-phase evaluation to assess traders’ ability to meet profit targets while managing risk.
  • Account Sizes: Account sizes range from $50,000 to $150,000.
  • Profit Share: After successfully passing the evaluation, traders keep up to 90% of their profits.
  • Risk Management: Strict rules include a $1,000 daily loss limit and a $2,000 maximum drawdown for funded traders.
  • Payout Frequency: Traders are paid every two weeks.

2. Overview of TradeDay

What is TradeDay?

TradeDay is another prominent proprietary trading firm offering funding to traders who can prove their ability to trade futures profitably. Founded by experienced traders, TradeDay is designed to provide traders with flexibility and access to capital while maintaining a focus on education and risk management. The firm offers a single-phase evaluation process, providing traders with a relatively straightforward path to becoming a funded trader.

Key Features:

  • Evaluation Process: TradeDay uses a single-phase evaluation to test traders’ abilities to generate profits.
  • Account Sizes: Account sizes available range from $25,000 to $250,000, giving traders more options.
  • Profit Share: Traders who are funded can keep up to 80%-90% of their profits, depending on the plan.
  • Risk Management: TradeDay has a $1,000 daily loss limit and $3,000 maximum drawdown for funded traders.
  • Payout Frequency: TradeDay provides weekly payouts, offering traders more frequent access to their earnings compared to Topstep.

3. Evaluation Process: Topstep vs. TradeDay

The evaluation process is a key element when selecting a proprietary trading firm, as it determines the path to accessing a funded account. Both Topstep and TradeDay have different evaluation structures, which may suit traders depending on their experience, strategy, and trading style.

Topstep Evaluation Process:

  • Phase 1: Traders need to achieve a $3,000 profit target within 15 trading days, while adhering to a strict $1,000 daily loss limit.
  • Phase 2: In the second phase, traders must meet another $3,000 profit target in 10 trading days, following the same risk management rules.
  • Evaluation Focus: Topstep’s two-phase evaluation process is designed to assess traders’ ability to generate consistent profits over a two-phase process, which may appeal to more disciplined traders.

TradeDay Evaluation Process:

  • Single Phase Evaluation: Traders must achieve a $2,000 profit target with a $1,000 daily loss limit in a 30-day period.
  • Evaluation Focus: TradeDay’s single-phase evaluation is simpler and less stressful, giving traders more time to meet their profit target without the pressure of two phases. This flexibility can be appealing for traders who want to take their time to prove their consistency.

4. Profit Share and Payouts: Topstep vs. TradeDay

Profit share and payout frequency are critical aspects of any proprietary trading firm, as they determine how much traders can keep from their earnings and how often they can access their profits.

Topstep Profit Share:

  • Profit Share: Topstep offers up to 90% profit share after traders pass the evaluation and are funded.
  • Payout Frequency: Payouts are made bi-weekly, meaning traders can access their profits every two weeks.

TradeDay Profit Share:

  • Profit Share: TradeDay offers a profit share ranging from 80% to 90%, depending on the account and trader’s performance.
  • Payout Frequency: Payouts are made on a weekly basis, which means traders can access their profits more frequently than with Topstep.

5. Risk Management: Topstep vs. TradeDay

Risk management is one of the most important factors in a trader’s success. Both Topstep and TradeDay have strict rules to ensure that traders do not exceed their set loss limits, but they differ in some aspects.

Topstep Risk Management:

  • Daily Loss Limit: $1,000 daily loss limit for funded accounts.
  • Maximum Drawdown: $2,000 maximum drawdown for funded accounts.
  • Leverage: Topstep offers 1:100 leverage, which provides traders more flexibility in their positions.

TradeDay Risk Management:

  • Daily Loss Limit: $1,000 daily loss limit for funded accounts.
  • Maximum Drawdown: $3,000 maximum drawdown for funded accounts.
  • Leverage: TradeDay offers 1:50 leverage, which is more conservative than Topstep’s 1:100 leverage.

6. Key Differences: Topstep vs. TradeDay

FeatureTopstepTradeDay
Profit ShareUp to 90%80% – 90%
Evaluation ProcessTwo-phase (15 days and 10 days)Single-phase (30 days)
Account Sizes$50,000 to $150,000$25,000 to $250,000
Risk Management$1,000 daily loss limit, $2,000 max drawdown$1,000 daily loss limit, $3,000 max drawdown
Payout FrequencyBi-weeklyWeekly

7. Conclusion: Topstep vs. TradeDay – Which is Right for You?

Both Topstep and TradeDay offer excellent opportunities for traders looking to get funded, but the right choice ultimately depends on your preferences for evaluation structure, risk management, and payout frequency.

  • Choose Topstep if you prefer a two-phase evaluation process and don’t mind the additional pressure of achieving profit targets in shorter timeframes. The firm’s bi-weekly payouts and 90% profit share for successful traders make it an attractive option for disciplined traders who thrive under pressure.
  • Choose TradeDay if you prefer a single-phase evaluation with more time to meet profit targets (30 days). TradeDay’s weekly payouts and slightly higher maximum drawdown make it a good choice for traders who prefer a more flexible approach to their evaluation and prefer faster access to their profits.

In the end, both firms provide unique opportunities for traders to scale their trading careers with real capital, but the decision comes down to how you prefer to manage your evaluation and risk, as well as your desire for payout frequency and profit sharing. Whether you choose Topstep or TradeDay, both platforms offer solid paths to becoming a successful funded trader.

Prop Trading Firms

Prop Trading Firms

ProprietaryFirms.com is a website dedicated to reviewing prop trading firms. With an increasing demand of aspiring traders who are looking to get a funded account, there are more and more prop trading firms popping up nowadays. We can help traders to find the prop firms that meet their needs.

Prop Firms
Logo